As the 2025 NFL Draft approaches, the Carolina Panthers are faced with a crucial decision at the No. 8 overall pick. With a glaring need for a top-tier wide receiver and multiple holes to fill on defense, the Panthers have a lot to consider as they look to build a competitive team around quarterback Bryce Young. While the pre-draft process is still unfolding, there’s one risky, high-reward prospect that has caught the Panthers’ attention.
One of the names generating buzz is wide receiver Tetairoa McMillan, a dynamic playmaker who could provide a significant boost to Carolina’s receiving corps. With Young needing a reliable No. 1 target, McMillan’s skill set would undoubtedly help the Panthers’ offense. However, the decision to select McMillan at No. 8 is not without controversy. While many believe he has the talent to be a game-changer at the next level, there is still debate across the league about whether he is truly worthy of a top-10 selection. Some scouts view him as a bit of a gamble, raising questions about whether Carolina should take that risk at such a pivotal spot in the draft.
Despite the pressing need for a wide receiver, the Panthers may be leaning toward addressing a more immediate concern: their defense. Carolina’s defense ranked as the worst in the NFL last season, and there is a strong argument to be made that bolstering that side of the ball should be a priority. The Panthers have the opportunity to add a game-changing defender who can help turn things around quickly, especially as they continue to build around their young quarterback.
As the draft draws closer, it remains to be seen whether Carolina will stick with their offensive focus and select McMillan or prioritize a defensive addition that could provide an immediate impact. One thing is clear—there are plenty of decisions to make, and the Panthers’ No. 8 pick will be one of the most talked-about selections in the 2025 draft. With so much at stake, the Panthers’ front office will need to carefully weigh the risks and rewards of each prospect as they look to turn their franchise around.