In a headline-grabbing Bleacher Report trade proposal that’s setting the footy world ablaze, Collingwood Football Club is projected to pull off a massive midfield coup — acquiring Bailey Smith in a move that could transform the 2025 AFL season.
According to B/R analysts, the Magpies are poised to land the explosive former Bulldogs and current Geelong midfielder, whose game-breaking ability and elite endurance could be the missing link in Collingwood’s pursuit of back-to-back flags.
The Trade (Proposed):
•Collingwood receives:
•Bailey Smith (Midfielder – Geelong Cats)
•Geelong Cats receive:
•Fin Macrae (Midfielder)
•2025 First-Round Pick
•2026 Second-Round Pick
Why This Trade Changes Everything
Bailey Smith has been one of the most talked-about players in the AFL for years — not just for his flowing mullet and social media presence, but for his genuine impact on the field. In 2025, he has averaged 30+ disposals per game, with multiple clutch performances that remind fans of his 2021 finals heroics.
Pairing him with Nick Daicos, Jordan De Goey, and Scott Pendlebury (in a mentoring role) would give Collingwood arguably the most dangerous midfield rotation in the competition.
This proposed deal is built around Collingwood’s belief that Smith could be the difference-maker that pushes them from contenders to dynasty status.
AFL World Reacts
The internet couldn’t stay calm for long:
•“Bailey Smith in black and white? That’s footy cinema.”
•“Geelong losing their top midfielder? What are they thinking?”
•“If this happens, just hand Collingwood the cup already.”
Even players and media figures chimed in. One former Magpie star told SEN, “Smith’s work rate with Daicos’ IQ — it’s almost unfair.”
Geelong’s Perspective: Reset Mode?
Geelong, who scooped up Smith in a splashy off-season move from the Western Bulldogs, now face the dilemma of long-term balance. The proposed return gives them a young talent in Fin Macrae and critical draft capital to reshape their aging core.
It might sting in the short term — but could be smart business in a salary cap-driven league.
Final Take: Premiership Window Wide Open
If this B/R proposal becomes a reality, Collingwood just went from dangerous to deadly. Bailey Smith isn’t just a flashy name — he’s a two-way midfielder who can break lines, absorb pressure, and lift in clutch moments.
And with Nick Daicos already becoming the face of the league, adding another superstar to the Magpies midfield may make Collingwood the team to beat for the next 3–5 years.
Stay tuned. If this deal becomes more than speculation, expect a full-scale AFL media meltdown.