The pressure is on in Indianapolis. Quarterback Anthony Richardson has officially been named the Colts’ “make-or-break player” for the 2025 NFL season, according to multiple league insiders and team analysts. The designation comes after a rollercoaster rookie campaign and an injury-hampered 2024 that left both fans and the front office hungry for answers — and results.
Richardson, the No. 4 overall pick in the 2023 NFL Draft, enters his third year with the team amid rising expectations and dwindling patience. After showing flashes of elite dual-threat potential early in his career, inconsistency and health concerns have kept him from fully taking the reins as the Colts’ long-term franchise quarterback.
A Critical Year for Development and Results
Team insiders have made it clear: 2025 is the year Richardson must prove he can be both durable and dependable. With the Colts investing heavily in surrounding talent — including upgrades to the offensive line and skill positions — the onus is now squarely on the quarterback to lead the team into playoff contention.
“Anthony has everything you want — the arm, the athleticism, the leadership qualities,” one team executive told reporters. “But the time for potential is over. This is the year we need to see it come together on the field.”
Coaching Staff Rallies Behind Richardson
Colts head coach Shane Steichen, known for his quarterback-friendly system, continues to back Richardson publicly, citing the QB’s work ethic and commitment in offseason workouts. Steichen has also reportedly tailored parts of the playbook to maximize Richardson’s strengths, particularly in play-action and designed QB runs.
“He’s taken a big leap mentally this offseason,” said Steichen. “Now it’s about translating that growth into wins.”
The Stakes: Playoffs or Pivot?
The AFC South remains competitive, with the Jaguars and Texans both fielding strong young rosters. If the Colts fall behind again in 2025, there could be serious conversations about the future of the quarterback position in Indianapolis.
If Richardson delivers, however, the Colts could be one of the AFC’s most dangerous sleeper teams. If not, the franchise may face tough decisions heading into 2026 — possibly including a new quarterback search.
Bottom Line
Anthony Richardson is no longer just a prospect with sky-high upside — he’s the focal point of the Colts’ 2025 campaign. With the spotlight squarely on him, this season could define his NFL career — and the direction of the franchise for years to come.